User:SetsunaKnowsTheMatrix/RFD/Fly

Discussion

 * Scrooge200 (talk) 06:19, 24 July 2022 (UTC)
 * Jensonk
 * WoofWoofGam3r
 * Could this article be merged with the PA System from SpongeBob’s Big Birthday Blowout or other PA systems in the show like how the hotline page was restored? I think it could be a good way to make the page less unneeded and more likely to not be deleted. I do hope that somebody can respond to this if they have the chance. (Also this is like the third time I made an article for something in season 13 and it getting deleted). MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 15:41, 24 July 2022 (UTC)
 * Cokic na Xic
 * Yes
 * The plane could have an article. If needed, this could be described in a single sentence on that page. 02:02, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * Yeah I agree that the plane could have an article, but the speaker was unique enough to get its own page cause of the design and it actually having dialogue. If it was just a normal speaker than yeah it wouldn’t need an article, but the fact it was personified does warrant it in my opinion. Besides it appeared longer than the clarinet or scallops that were also personified after SpongeBob and Patrick. I am pretty sure there are articles with less info that keep their page yet this one gets a deletion request despite having enough info for an article? Weird how that works. MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 03:43, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * I think a general plane article could work Boatmobile article. As for information, it's because I don't think the scene is meant to imply the speaker is actually sentient as much as just being there to visually communicate the idea that SpongeBob and Patrick are speaking through it. And for that second part, I evaluate articles as I come across them and they are created; I don't have some sorting algorithm of articles by necessity and quality. Scrooge200 (talk) 04:22, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * True, I do see your point (even if I do believe the speaker was personified), but I wanted to add another thing. In the episode "Ghost Host" there was a sentient clarinet named Ghost Clairinette that shared the exact same voice as the Flying Dutchman. However, it was shown in a storyboard that the Ghost Clairinette was indeed the one talking (although it could have been a puppet, as it’s name is a pun on the word marionette). I am saying this because the speaker could be similar to Ghost Clairinette, as it sounds exactly the same as another character, but is personified enough to warrant an article. I also stated in the trivia that there were other personified characters/objects designed and sounding exactly like SpongeBob and Patrick. But unlike those ones, the speaker did appear for a decent chunk of time (for sentient object standards) and actually had dialogue. I am down for further discussion if you need to. MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 05:58, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * Yes
 * The plane could have an article. If needed, this could be described in a single sentence on that page. 02:02, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * Yeah I agree that the plane could have an article, but the speaker was unique enough to get its own page cause of the design and it actually having dialogue. If it was just a normal speaker than yeah it wouldn’t need an article, but the fact it was personified does warrant it in my opinion. Besides it appeared longer than the clarinet or scallops that were also personified after SpongeBob and Patrick. I am pretty sure there are articles with less info that keep their page yet this one gets a deletion request despite having enough info for an article? Weird how that works. MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 03:43, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * I think a general plane article could work Boatmobile article. As for information, it's because I don't think the scene is meant to imply the speaker is actually sentient as much as just being there to visually communicate the idea that SpongeBob and Patrick are speaking through it. And for that second part, I evaluate articles as I come across them and they are created; I don't have some sorting algorithm of articles by necessity and quality. Scrooge200 (talk) 04:22, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * True, I do see your point (even if I do believe the speaker was personified), but I wanted to add another thing. In the episode "Ghost Host" there was a sentient clarinet named Ghost Clairinette that shared the exact same voice as the Flying Dutchman. However, it was shown in a storyboard that the Ghost Clairinette was indeed the one talking (although it could have been a puppet, as it’s name is a pun on the word marionette). I am saying this because the speaker could be similar to Ghost Clairinette, as it sounds exactly the same as another character, but is personified enough to warrant an article. I also stated in the trivia that there were other personified characters/objects designed and sounding exactly like SpongeBob and Patrick. But unlike those ones, the speaker did appear for a decent chunk of time (for sentient object standards) and actually had dialogue. I am down for further discussion if you need to. MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 05:58, 25 July 2022 (UTC)
 * True, I do see your point (even if I do believe the speaker was personified), but I wanted to add another thing. In the episode "Ghost Host" there was a sentient clarinet named Ghost Clairinette that shared the exact same voice as the Flying Dutchman. However, it was shown in a storyboard that the Ghost Clairinette was indeed the one talking (although it could have been a puppet, as it’s name is a pun on the word marionette). I am saying this because the speaker could be similar to Ghost Clairinette, as it sounds exactly the same as another character, but is personified enough to warrant an article. I also stated in the trivia that there were other personified characters/objects designed and sounding exactly like SpongeBob and Patrick. But unlike those ones, the speaker did appear for a decent chunk of time (for sentient object standards) and actually had dialogue. I am down for further discussion if you need to. MontyMoleLoreMaster (talk) 05:58, 25 July 2022 (UTC)


 * I will literally cry if this gets deleted.
 * I like Kandy Katie's idea.
 * 's idea could actually work.
 * This page is cool ig
 * srsly this is not needed, like, this is basically just SpongeBob and Patrick's mouths
 * 's idea could actually work.
 * This page is cool ig
 * srsly this is not needed, like, this is basically just SpongeBob and Patrick's mouths
 * srsly this is not needed, like, this is basically just SpongeBob and Patrick's mouths